My Learning Source › Workshops & Articles

What a New Jersey School District Can and Can't Ask a Homeschool Family: The "Credible Evidence" Standard

By My Learning Source · November 22, 2026 · Guides, Tips

A district office calls and asks for your curriculum, a schedule and last year's test scores. Do you have to send them? In New Jersey, the Department of Education (DOE) has answered that question in writing, and the answer is mostly no. Here is where the line sits and how to handle a request politely without giving away more than the law asks. Our New Jersey Homeschool Options guide has the wider picture.

The district's job

Districts are not bystanders. The DOE's homeschooling FAQ says: "The local board of education is required to enforce the compulsory education law, N.J.S.A. 18A:38-25." So a district has a legitimate interest in whether a child is being educated somewhere. What it doesn't have is authority over how you do it.

What a district is "not required or authorized" to do

The FAQ uses the phrase "not required or authorized" again and again. That second word matters: it isn't only that a district may skip these things, it's that the DOE says the district has no authority to do them.

  • Approve your curriculum. "The law does not require or authorize the local board of education to review and approve the curriculum or program of a child educated elsewhere than at school."
  • Monitor results. "The local board of education is not required or authorized to monitor the outcomes of the child."
  • Test your child. "The local board of education is not required or authorized to test a child educated elsewhere than at school." The FAQ adds that the board "does not have to ensure through testing or another mechanism that instruction is being appropriately delivered or achieving its desired effect, to review the quality of instruction, or to monitor the results."
  • Approve outside programs. For correspondence courses, online programs or outside teachers, "The state or local board of education is not required or authorized to approve the selected program."

The FAQ also says a parent teaching at home doesn't need a New Jersey teaching certificate.

When a district may ask for something

There is one door, and the DOE describes it precisely: "If the local board of education determines that there is credible evidence that the parent/guardian or other person(s) having custody and control of a school-age child is not causing the child either to attend school (public or nonpublic) or to receive equivalent instruction elsewhere than at school, the board may request documentation, such as a letter of intent from the parent/guardian confirming that the child is either attending a nonpublic school or receiving equivalent instruction elsewhere than at school."

Three things to notice. The trigger is "credible evidence" that a child isn't being educated. The request is for "documentation, such as a letter of intent." And the content of that letter is a confirmation of where the child is being educated, not a curriculum review.

Withdrawal is not evidence

The next sentence is the one to underline: "The mere fact that a child has been withdrawn to be homeschooled is not, in itself, credible evidence of a legal violation."

So a district can't treat your withdrawal as the reason to demand paperwork. Something more has to be there, and the FAQ leaves it to the board to identify what that evidence is.

If the district still has concerns

The FAQ says: "If it appears that the child is not receiving an education in accordance with N.J.S.A. 18A:38-25, the board may wish to consult with its attorney regarding possible charges against the parent/guardian for failure to have the child educated." The charge would be under N.J.S.A. 18A:38-31, a disorderly persons offense with a fine of not more than

5 for a first offense and not more than
00 for each later offense, as the statute reads in 2026.

If it ever came to that, the question in court is whether your instruction is academically equivalent to the local public school's (State v. Massa, as the DOE summarizes it). That's why your own records matter so much more than anything you send the district.

Things you can ask the district for

The flow runs both ways. Parents "may seek information about the school curriculum from the local board of education," and "the board must provide it since a district's curriculum is a matter of public record," though you can be charged copying costs. A board "may, but is under no obligation to, loan books or materials." Participation in classes, clubs or sports is at the board's "sole discretion."

A family who got a letter

Nadia pulled her two children from an Essex County elementary school in October. In November the district sent a form asking for her curriculum, weekly schedule and a plan for standardized testing. She called the attendance office, said politely that she was providing equivalent instruction elsewhere than at school under 18A:38-25, and asked whether the district had any information suggesting her children weren't being educated. They said no; the form was routine. She sent back a one-paragraph letter confirming that both children were receiving equivalent instruction at home, kept a copy, and left the other boxes blank. She kept her own binder, with reading logs and work samples, at home.

(A composite example — names and details are illustrative, drawn from situations homeschool families commonly describe.)

Her letter gave the district what it can document. Her binder is what would answer the Massa question if it were ever asked.

How to answer a request

  • Stay polite and put everything in writing. Phone calls leave no record.
  • Ask what prompted the request. Routine forms are common; credible-evidence requests should come with a reason.
  • A short letter confirming that your child is receiving equivalent instruction elsewhere than at school answers what the FAQ describes.
  • Curricula, schedules and test plans are not things the DOE says a board may approve or review.
  • If the district says it has credible evidence or mentions charges, talk to a New Jersey attorney before you send anything else.
  • Keep your records current all year, not only when a letter arrives.

What might change

Two 2026 bills would give districts more contact. A3394 would require a yearly portfolio with "an annual written evaluation of the student's educational progress as determined by a qualified evaluator," submitted to the superintendent by June 30. A1341 and its Senate twin S741 would require a yearly meeting with a district counselor, nurse or social worker, who would "conduct a general health and wellness check of the child." All three were referred to the education committees on January 13, 2026, and none has moved since. They are not law.

Find curriculum, tutors, classes and record-keeping help in our vendor directory, New Jersey events on the Education Calendar, and other New Jersey families in our community.

My Learning Source is an independent marketplace and is not affiliated with the New Jersey Department of Education, the New Jersey Legislature or any school district. This is general information, not legal advice — if a district raises a compliance concern, confirm your position with a New Jersey attorney before you act. Family examples are composites, not real individuals.


More from the marketplace

Loading the full experience… If it does not appear, this article is fully readable above.